PHOTOBOOK REVIEWS, INTERVIEWS AND WRITE-UPS
ALONG WITH THE LATEST PHOTO-EYE NEWS

Social Media


photo-eye Gallery New Work – Tom Chambers: Still Beating photo-eye Gallery is proud to introduce Still Beating the newest series of photomontages by represented artist Tom Chambers. Based on dreams and musings, Chambers' work sits firmly in the expressive genre of magic realism, and Still Beating focuses on the vitality of life under threat and the contrast between bodily fragility and emotional fortitude.

Fire and Ice, 2017 – © Tom Chambers, Archival Pigment Print, 20 x 20 inches
photo-eye Gallery is proud to introduce Still Beating the newest series of photomontages by represented artist Tom Chambers. For over twenty years now, Chambers has been crafting affecting single setting narratives where the fantastic mingles with the plausible to create compelling meaningful images. Based on dreams and musings, Chambers' work sits firmly in the expressive genre of magic realism, and Still Beating focuses on the vitality of life under threat and the contrast between bodily fragility and emotional fortitude. Gallery Director Anne Kelly spoke with Tom and asked him to share some additional detail about his process, the creation of one of Still Beating's signature images, and what's next for the photographer.

Hidden Aviary, 2017 – ©Tom Chambers, Archival Pigment Print, 20 x 20 inches

Anne Kelly:
     Can you tell us a little about Still Beating; what were you thinking about while making the series?

Tom Chambers:     Since I began creating photomontage, storytelling has been part of all my series and something that has engaged the viewer. My hope has been that the viewer will look at my images, each of which contains an unfinished story, and then create his own interpretation of what's seen. As I began working on the Still Beating series, I wanted to strengthen the narrative in each of my images, while continuing to leave the meaning of the stories up to each individual viewer. What in the world is going on in Hidden Aviary with the young girl covered in leaves and playing with birds? In Fire and Ice, how did that innocent child dressed in summery clothing collect wood on a beach littered with ice? Some of these things are not quite right.

Magic realism has been a tool for me to create a strong narrative. I use magic realism to peak viewer's interests compelling them to take a second look because something looks different or improbable, and in Still Beating I use magic realism to enhance the narrative about the challenge of survival. No Glory in Regret pictures a young girl stroking a bird with a bow and arrow next to her in the grass. What will happen to the bird and the child? There don¹t have to be answers to these questions. I really just want to raise questions in the viewer's mind.

No Glory in Regret, 2017 – ©Tom Chambers, Archival Pigment Print, 20 x 20 inches

AK:     You have been creating photomontages for about twenty years now; how has your process changed or evolved over that time?

TC:     Although I had my first exhibition 20 years ago, I started working with digital images when Photoshop was first released around 1990.  Early on, I was shooting with a Minolta 35mm film camera and scanning those transparencies with a film scanner, and it didn’t take me too long to realize that a medium format camera would be necessary for output to 20” prints.  So, in 2004 I switched to a Mamiya 645 film camera and was able to print much larger.  In 2007 I felt that digital cameras had advanced to the stage where the image quality was close to that of film.  Not only that, but film and scanning costs were very hindering, so at that point, I started shooting with a Nikon D300 and later switched to a D800.  I have also learned that image quality is very dependent on a sharp lens, and more recently have invested in multiple quality lenses.

Photoshop software has also evolved in a major way since I first began experimenting with the software.  In the early days, there was no such thing as using layers for the different elements.  After layers for elements became available, the ability to work with adjustment layers was introduced, which meant you could independently modify each element of the constructed image.

In terms of how I plan my images, I’ve always worked the same way. I typically do a thumbnail sketch of an idea and use that as a guide to shoot the separate elements. Although I often use images photographed while traveling as backgrounds for my photomontage, the elements typically are shot near my home, either outdoors or in a studio.

Where Salt Meets Sky, 2017 – ©Tom Chambers, Archival Pigment Print, 20 x 20 inches

AK:     We see a lot of birds in your work; do they mean anything in particular to you?

TC:     To me, a bird symbolizes the expression of freedom.  Many viewers easily connect to birds. And quite honestly, who doesn’t love birds?  When birds are portrayed as being caught or restrained, it sometimes throws the viewer off balance or makes him uncomfortable.  My goal is to help the viewer to emotionally connect with the image and to draw the viewer into the image.

Garden Gate, 2017 – ©Tom Chambers, Archival Pigment Print, 20 x 20 inches

AK:     Please choose an image from Still Beating and detail how it was made or what it means to you?

TC:     In making the image Garden Gate, I traveled to Portugal two years ago and had the opportunity to explore the Convent of the Capuchos.  This ancient convent is set in a very rural area and upon entering you cross under a low stone arch which symbolizes leaving the material world and entering the spiritual. Trees are thick within the convent grounds and the stone buildings are covered with moss and lichens. I believe we were the only people there. I could visualize animals coming through the area during the late hours and I decided to illustrate that idea by using a deer walking down a set of steps to an open gate. The deer itself draws interest to the image, but the addition of the boy partially hidden behind the open gate gives it a narrative.

Come What Is, 2017 – ©Tom Chambers, Archival Pigment Print, 20 x 20 inches
AK:     We've heard rumors of a new forthcoming book; are you able to share any information about the project with us?

TC:     Several months ago, I was surprised and honored to be contacted by a representative of the Unicorn Publishing Group (London) who expressed interest in publishing a retrospective book of my work.  The production of the book has started and the release is scheduled for Fall 2018. The is book entitled Hearts & Bones will be 208 pages in length and include my nine photo series.


–––

Entropic Kingdom by Tom Chambers
ModernBook, 2012
Archival Pigment Prints from Still Beating are available in limited editions in various sizes. Please inquire with Gallery Staff at 505-988-5152 x 202 or gallery@photoeye.com for more information, and to purchase prints. 


» View Still Beating

» View Additional Work by 
   Tom Chambers

» View Books by Tom Chambers

Book of the Week Book of the Week: A Pick by Laura M. André Laura M. André selects Eternal Friendship by Anouck Durand as Book of the Week.
Eternal FriendshipBy Anouck DurandSiglio, 2017.

Laura M. André picks Anouck Durand's Eternal Friendship, from Siglio, as Book of the Week.


A timely book about dictatorships, propaganda and friendship. Imagine Art Spiegelman meets Chris Marker, told in gorgeous 'tricolor' photography. 


—Richard McGuire

When I read this review quote about Anouck Durand's photo-novel, Eternal Friendship, I knew I'd be sold on the book even before I glimpsed between its covers. And I wasn't disappointed when I did.

The book is based on an extraordinary, true story about two men—both photographers—who met during the Nazi invasion of Albania in 1939. Refik Veseli, a left-wing Muslim, took Jewish photographer Mosha Mandil and his family into the Veseli home, where Mandil's wife and two children blended into Veseli's family and remained hidden until Albania was liberated by the Soviets in 1944.

After the war, Mandil and his family moved to Israel, while Veseli stayed in Albania, hoping to contribute to the building of a new and prosperous nation. Instead, Albania became an isolated, Communist dictatorship. It is several decades after that, in 1970, that French artist Anouck Durand picks up the story, which I won't spoil for you here, in China. And she tells it masterfully, combining archival, state-sponsored imagery with hand-written captions and passages that reconstruct Veseli's efforts to reconnect with his dear friend despite their distance and the powerful regimes that stand in the way.

Weaving together the personal, political, historical, and fictional, Durand relates Veseli's story within the larger conflict between China and Albania, and its massive propaganda, censorship, and history-obliterating machines. ("Alternative facts" and "fake news," anyone?) The resulting photo-novel is a call to resist the attempts of great powers to alter history and erase memory, and a poignant recognition that it is in our personal efforts to connect that we can hope to express and retain our humanity.  —Laura M. André

Purchase Book or read more


Eternal FriendshipBy Anouck DurandSiglio, 2017.
Eternal FriendshipBy Anouck DurandSiglio, 2017.
Eternal FriendshipBy Anouck DurandSiglio, 2017.


Laura M. André received her PhD in art history from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and taught photo history at the University of New Mexico before leaving academia to work with photobooks. She is the manager of photo-eye's book division.

See more Book of the Week picks


photo-eye Gallery Interview: Jennifer Greenburg on Revising History Gallery Associate Savannah Sakry interviews Jennifer Greenburg about her series Revising History.

photo-eye Gallery is delighted to have four works currently on view from Jennifer Greenburg's series Revising History above our flat files. These striking images have captivated Gallery visitors all summer with the questions – are these contemporary works, and how on earth does she place herself so seamlessly into a photograph which appears to have been taken decades ago? Gallery Associate Savannah Sakry asked Greenburg to share more on the provoking project and enlighten us on her process. Two new images are making their debut to the series and Greenburg notes her recent direction for the project is "images that are aesthetically beautiful, yet conceptually grotesque..." Works from Revising History are on display through September 9th, 2017.

Savannah Sakry:     When did you first fall in love with photography or decide on the medium?

Jennifer Greenburg:     I grew up around a lot of models, actors, and performers and therefore I grew up around a lot of photography.  I also experienced a lot of loss throughout my childhood due to various factors, including the AIDS crisis of the early 1980’s. I connected with photography because it was a way for me to hold on to those that I had lost.  Whenever I was sad, I would open up one of the many photo albums my mother had painstakingly compiled, and somehow I would feel a lot better after I looked at the photographs of those that I had lost. It was as though the person was there with me again.

I never really “decided” to be a photographer.  It was just something I knew I would do.  I never even talked about it with anyone until I began to apply to study photography in college. There was no choice, as far as I remember.

SS:     Your first project “The Rockabillies” is a thoughtfully composed series of portraits examining today’s rockabilly subculture. Shot in color, and with a 4 x 5 view camera, It’s my understanding the sittings were often a collaboration between you and the subjects, whom you are quite fond of. How did you arrive from “The Rockabillies” to “Revising History”? 

JG:     I began The Rockabillies early in 2001, right after September 11. I embarked on the project in order to discover contemporary methods for building communities that do not rely on birthrights, ethnicity, or station. It was a time when having a community was especially important as the nation forever changed that day and I wanted a way to make sense of a collective new reality.

At that time,  I believed in documentary photography as a method for conveying honest information. I spent ten years on that project, getting to know everyone I photographed in a deep and meaningful way. I collaborated with my subjects in an effort to be as fair and honest as possible. I thought the people and places I interacted with were remarkable. Everyone I photographed was open, honest and trusting.

Ultimately, however, my pictures were taken through the lens of my experience. I saw what I wanted to see. And I questioned if there was a difference between what I had done, and what FOX News does every day. Pictures convince us of truth more than words.

My affection for pre-war and mid-century America was, and is, rooted in clothing, design, and ephemera. The aesthetic rapture caused by the visual record of that time period easily allows us to forget the gender and racial inequality, the Anti-Semitism, and many other injustices. Noticing how easy it is to gloss over those realities when looking at old photographs allowed me to think of Revising History.

I wanted to meet a rich husband, so I modeled in auto shows, 2016 © Jennifer Greenburg | Archival Pigment Print, 24 x 30", Edition of 5


SS:     Your current project is mainly in black and white and you work initially from a found vernacular negative. It’s apparent, (though not actually), you are utilizing a digital technique to its full potential. Was this process or path something you were already exploring or was it a result of the initial conception of “Revising History”?

JG:     I thought of the concept for the project a long time before I knew how to execute the final form. I had the skills to make it happen, but, the complexities of production of Revising History exceed any one skill set. My images go far beyond digital image making. There is a lot involved!

I spent over a year making complete failures before I was able to come up with an acceptable final image. I still make a lot of images that end up being unseen failures, but, I had no successes in that first year. Something Funny Happened in the Kitchen, 2011, was the first image that worked. I am depicted hysterically laughing, in the image, because I was on the verge of a complete mental breakdown. I had been shooting for hours that day, and had shot every day that week. Everything had been garbage and I was at the end of my rope. I was laughing and crying from frustration and I was about to give up the entire endeavor. But I was laughing too hard to stop, and so I kept firing the trigger. Once I was able to review what I had done, I realized the image might work, and I persevered.

Something funny happened in the kitchen, 2011 © Jennifer Greenburg | Archival Pigment Print, 30 x 24", Edition of 4




































SS:     While you replace the central figure of the original negative with a photograph of yourself, these works are not autobiographical, correct?

None of my images are self-portraits, however, I choose images that depict a character experiencing something that I find identifiable.  I study each image very closely and I try to figure out who the subject was, and what she was experiencing the moment the image was taken. I transform into the woman who was there, and I become a translation of her. In that, the work is more a performance than any other categorization.

The insurance agent told me to have my father or my husband call him, 2017 © Jennifer Greenburg | Archival Pigment Print, 32 x 40", Edition of 3
SS:     Each image must be very time-consuming. Can you briefly walk me through your process from start to finish? What are the required “ingredients”?

JG:     Each image takes several hundred hours to make after I have done the initial preparation.  The initial preparation takes years.  I have an archive of vernacular images that takes up an entire room in my house and I have to study and consider every frame.  I like to receive images in a big, dirty, box, fresh from a basement or an attic. I do not like anything to have been sorted.  I go through every frame, and put each strip or image into an archival sleeve.  I look for an image that can serve as a punctum and a symbol:  an image that a viewer would find relatable in its narrative. 

The image I choose dictates what happens next.  I could not walk you through my process because I have no process; every single image I have made presents new challenges and requires new solutions. Every time I think I know how to make something, or go in with a shred of self-confidence,  I either fail or the process takes longer than ever before. My newest image officially took longer than any previous image. I am very happy with the results, but I am not sure I would do it again if I had known what I was up against. 

SS:     When you are not in your studio or teaching, you are actively pursuing you first passion - vintage jewelry and clothing. Is it true your extensive collection began at the age of 4?

JG:     Yes, I was 4. My first purchase was made during a neighborhood indoor-yard sale on Astor street in Chicago. The famed Wrigley Mansion had rooms full of toys, but, I was only interested in a pair of 1940’s chandelier earrings, and an oversized rhinestone cocktail ring presented in a red-velvet celluloid box.  My parents asked me multiple times if I really wanted the jewelry, instead of a toy. Then they asked where I was going to wear the jewelry. I don’t remember my answer, but, apparently it was satisfactory because I still have both items.

SS:     In light of Cindy Sherman’s Instagram account recently going public (I see we are mutual followers) is her work inspirational to you? Either conceptually or for performative reasons?

JG:     Absolutely. Every photographer born in the latter half of the 20th century, or after,  should be inspired by Cindy Sherman. I remember, vividly, seeing her work for the first time when I was 17.  It was the first project that allowed me to understand what was involved in a contemporary body of work made with a camera.

SS:     Who are your largest influences and inspirations?

JG:     It’s hard for me to make lists and I hate putting things in hierarchies.  How can I choose between Diane Arbus and James Van Der Zee? Measure the personal impact Carrie Mae Weems has had on my work? Nan Goldin? Larry Sultan?  It’s impossible – I love it all.  And it’s all deeply important to me.

I was lucky enough to be friends with Greer Lankton in the last few years of her life, and her work and legacy has been a constant influence. 

I am also influenced by performance artists, writers, and comedians.  I am always trying to sculpt a humorous yet dark narrative in my work, and it is easier to find inspiration in arenas like comedy and performance. I utilize a lot of camp in my work to achieve that balance.  I am a lifelong fan of John Waters, RuPaul, Mae West, Divine, Angelyne, Orlan, Yoko Ono, Cher, Liberace… I could go on forever. 

SS:     Can you touch on your clever titles, and themes you wish to address? As a woman, your work resonates with me on several levels, and is one of the many reasons I fell in love with the project.

Portrait of Greenburg's Grandmother
JG:     My grandmother (pictured left) used to write funny things on the back of photographs.   She and I used to look through her photos together and she would editorialize the images and tell me all about the people and the places in the images.  She was born in 1905-ish and her entire life, in photographs, was one glamourous outfit after another, which is why I was, and still am,  deeply engrossed in looking at her pictures. 

We would come across “defaced” people in her photographs– images that had faces scratched right off the print!  I would ask my grandmother why she had done this and she would usually launch into an interesting story of betrayal and intrigue. I was fascinated that my grandma, who had only ever shown me unequivocal love, had been involved in this type of strive. I was also amused that she had no sense of sanctity for the original image. I am sure there is an obvious connection between her “defacement projects” and Revising History.

I got the initial captioning, and perhaps the underpinnings of the project from her tradition. 

However,  the captioning has evolved as I have grown more bold in my making of Revising History. During the first part of my career, I made joyous images. I did not want to be reminded of horrible things and therefore I only made images that were ebullient. But I was avoiding my reality.

My lifelong study of photography has lead me to conclude that photographs are the primary catalyst in allowing us to rewriting our history. All it takes is that glamourous outfit and a good hair-do to make us say, “Things used to be better!” I spent my childhood thinking that my grandmother had lived in better times.  The truth is that my grandmother had no college education because women, in her day, were not educated.  She experienced painful Anti-Semitism when in non-Jewish environments, and lost most of her cousins in the Holocaust. But she looked good through all of these hardships! And therefore we are duped by her remaining legacy: her photographs. 

My titles serve to peel back the artifice of my pictures. 

I have never been good at handling unwarranted attention, 2015 © Jennifer Greenburg | Archival Pigment Print, 24 x 30", Edition of 3

SS:     Of the four pieces currently on display, which is your favorite image and why?

JG:     I have a hard time picking favorites in any context, as I mentioned before. However, I would probably choose, I have never been good at handling unwarranted attention, 2015. Why? Because I have had a very hard time handling unwarranted attention over the course of my life, beginning when I was a small child. The image is probably the most autobiographical image in the series. I know every woman, and many men,  can relate to the uncomfortable moment depicted in the image. The image is aesthetically beautiful, yet conceptually grotesque. I like that tension and am creating all of my new works under that guise. 

SS:     Would you say this project is nearing an end or is there more history to be revised by Jennifer Greenburg?

JG:     I feel as though I haven’t even gotten started. The new work is more bold, and much darker. I am becoming less apprehensive to discuss challenging cultural realities. Stay tuned!

--------------------------

Installation of Jennifer Greenburg's Revising History at photo-eye Gallery - On view through Sept. 9th, 2017

For more information or to purchase prints, please contact the Gallery Staff at 505.988.5152 x202 or gallery@photoeye.com. 





Book of the Week Book of the Week: A Pick by Christian Michael Filardo Christian Michael Filardo selects Wannabe by Elisa González Miralles as Book of the Week.
WannabeBy Elisa González Miralles La Fábrica, 2017.
Christian Michael Filardo picks Wannabe by Elisa González Miralles from La Fábrica as Book of the Week.

"Wannabe by Elisa González Miralles analyzes and dissects society’s concept of identity by juxtaposing images of Japanese love dolls with real women and puffer fish. Blurring the lines between the real and the surrogate, González Miralles asks us to focus in order to separate the fake from the authentic. A quick flip through this book provokes a feeling similar to the feeling one receives when witnessing a magician perform an illusion. Wannabe makes those who choose to look surrender their perception of reality.

Intensely red, the images of the puffer fish in this book give Wannabe an aura of a deep dark lust and desire. The bloodied and wet fish paired with the love dolls elevates the alien quality of the dolls to an extreme and in some cases, seems to sexualize the dolls further. This book is eerie and fascinating, and at times reminds me of the self-portrait work of Tomoko Sawada in the way it skews identity to such a radical level. Curiously, the lifelike nature of the dolls makes me ask the question; why are people so drawn to these realistic imitations? Unnerving, Wannabe draws attention to the fact that people are moving farther away from real life in exchange for simulation. Thus, the relevance of this book seems obvious given the day and age we live in. With the advent of virtual reality and an omnipresent app culture infiltrating our everyday.

Ultimately, this book is quite a thought-provoking and jarring experience adorned in a red latex dust jacket. Wonderfully paced and beautifully printed, I find myself lost in the creepy decadence of Wannabe very easily. González Miralles has created something special here that will likely prove to be an important monograph for years to come. Wannabe is a triumph worthy of any photobook fans’ time."  — Christian Michael Filardo

Purchase Book

WannabeBy Elisa González Miralles La Fábrica, 2017.

WannabeBy Elisa González Miralles La Fábrica, 2017.


Christian Michael Filardo is a Filipino-American composer and photographer living and working in Santa Fe, New Mexico. He recently had a solo exhibition called Tumbleweed Replica at Current Space in Baltimore, MD and is the current shipping manager at photo-eye bookstore.

See more Book of the Week picks


photo-eye Gallery John Chervinsky Emerging Photographer Scholarship 2017 The Griffin Museum of Photography in Winchester, MA is offering a scholarship to aid emerging photographers in honor of Photographer's Showcase artist and our friend, John Chervinsky, who passed away in 2015.The John Chervinsky Emerging Photographer Scholarship seeks to recognize, encourage and reward photographers with the potential to create a body of work and sustain solo exhibitions.

John Chervinsky
The Griffin Museum of Photography in Winchester, MA is offering a scholarship to aid emerging photographers in honor of Photographer's Showcase artist and our friend, John Chervinsky, who passed away in 2015. An engineer and scientist, as well as a photographer, John's work was experimental in nature primarily dealing with reality, perception, and representation. John was warm, humble, and engaging and is missed by all who knew him.

About the Scholarship


The John Chervinsky Emerging Photographer Scholarship seeks to recognize, encourage and reward photographers with the potential to create a body of work and sustain solo exhibitions. Awarded annually, the Scholarship provides recipients with a monetary award of $3,000, an exhibition of their work at the Griffin Museum of Photography, and a volume from John’s personal library of photography books. The Scholarship seeks to provide a watershed moment in the professional lives of emerging photographers, providing them with the support and encouragement necessary to develop, articulate and grow their own vision for photography.

Eligibility Criteria

The scholarship is open to photographers who have produced individual works of photography and/or are in the process of producing bodies of work.

We are looking for candidates who are serious about photography, whose potential is emerging and whose photography will benefit from this scholarship. Candidates should not be currently enrolled in a photography degree program. There is no age limit. There are no residency requirements.

Photographers without gallery representation who have not exhibited solo in a gallery/museum setting are eligible (coffee shop, community gallery, library etc. are eligible exhibition settings).

This scholarship is not for well-established photographers. Well-established photographers are individuals in mid-photography-careers and are seen by the public and peers as distinguished in the field of photography and have many accomplishments as a photographer. Please note again that an artist who has had SOLO exhibitions in established galleries/museums or has gallery representation will be considered too accomplished to receive this scholarship.

Submissions

The Hand of Man, John Chervinsky
Submissions may be made directly to the Griffin Museum gateway only. You will be asked for a brief biography and artistic cv (a single pdf that includes both bio and cv); a statement of artistic purpose/intent; a statement on the work supplied, and flattened rgb jpgs (1200 pixels on the longest side) of your photographs (minimum of 10/maximum of 14 photographs). Our gateway will assemble your input into one area on our web host site and give the jurors the ability to go there to view and also download a pdf as needed. You will be able to insert your text for statements  into the gateway application. No other means of submission will be accepted. All missing criteria will disqualify the submission. Emails will not be accepted as a method of submissions. It is recommended that great thought and effort be put into the artistic purpose/intent statement (see sample supplied).



APPLY HERE

Scholarship Dates and Deadlines:
August 1, 2017: Application period opens
September 5, 2017: Application period closes
Mid December, 2017: Announcement of 2017 scholarship recipient
March 2017: Award Ceremony

» Read More about the Griffin Museum
» Read Aline Smithson's Remembrance of John on Lenscratch


Book Review Lindbergh Winogrand Women By Garry Winogrand and Peter Lindbergh. Reviewed by Blake Andrews Lindbergh's project intersperses photographs from Winogrand's 1975 book Women Are Beautiful with a heavier dose of his own On Street, a series based on a young fashion model walking the gritty sidewalks of contemporary New York.
Lindbergh Winogrand Women 
Photographs by Garry Winogrand and Peter Lindbergh. Koenig Books, 2017. 
 
Lindbergh Winogrand Women
Reviewed by Blake Andrews.

Lindbergh Winogrand Women
Photographs by Garry Winogrand and Peter Lindbergh. Text by Joel Meyerowitz and Ralph Goetz.
Koenig Books, Köln, Germany, 2017. In English and German. 140 pp., four-color and black-and-white illustrations, 8¾x9x¾".


At first blush street photography and fashion photography don't have much in common. Street photographers work without preconception, using chance and improvisation. The resulting image is meant to be a self-contained entity without an ulterior motive. Fashion shooters typically work under more controlled conditions — often in an artificially lit studio — with output geared toward a specific style or product placement.

Apples and oranges, right?

Lindbergh Winogrand Women Photographs by Garry Winogrand and Peter Lindbergh. Koenig Books, 2017.

But perhaps they share more in common than meets the eye. As a thought experiment, what if you sprung loose a fashion model on a busy urban sidewalk, shot her in passing, and compared the results to found street photos? To push the issue, what if the comparison were to the foremost street photographer in history, Garry Winogrand? Would the fashion shots hold up in that company? Would they feel charged with street energy? In this context, would fashion still seem inherently different than candid photographs of strangers?

These are among the questions raised by Peter Lindbergh's latest book Lindbergh Winogrand Women, published in correlation with an exhibition in Dusseldorf last spring. Lindbergh's project intersperses photographs from Winogrand's 1975 book Women Are Beautiful with a heavier dose (roughly 3:1 ratio?) of his own On Street, a series based on a young fashion model walking the gritty sidewalks of contemporary New York. Lindbergh may employ a model but his inner street shooter yearns for unstaged candor. "I wanna photograph real people," he writes in the book, "not the model. What I'm interested in, is to find a certain reality behind the facade."

Lindbergh Winogrand Women Photographs by Garry Winogrand and Peter Lindbergh. Koenig Books, 2017.

Toward this end, he employs Winogrand's methodology. He uses a wide angle lens and black-and-white w conversion to capture the chaos of found pedestrian scenes in New York. His admiration for the master is clear, and the project is an homage of sorts. Winogrand quotes are followed in the book a page later by similar Lindbergh quotes. Winogrand's photos are generally sequenced with similar scenes shot by Lindbergh — Winogrand's photograph of women gesturing on a park bench followed by a Lindbergh photo of his model on a park bench, for one. Or Winogrand's posterior shot of a skirted woman framed at distance followed by Lindbergh's similar photo. Other sequences follow suit. If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, it's clear Lindbergh is a Winogrand fan.

But the photographs from On Street have a tough time standing up next to those from Women Are Beautiful. To be fair that's not entirely Lindbergh's fault. Winogrand leaves all challengers in the dust. His snapshot aesthetic and restless curiosity may appear accessible to the casual observer — and perhaps entrancing to a fashion shooter — but its loose nature belies his mastery.

Lindbergh Winogrand Women Photographs by Garry Winogrand and Peter Lindbergh. Koenig Books, 2017.

Even though emulating Winogrand is a Sisyphean task, Lindbergh has given it a shot. But Lindbergh's photographs of a model walking the sidewalks feel like fashion, not street. Whatever realistic edge they possess is continually blunted by their main subject, a beautiful blonde model wearing haute couture: To his credit, Lindbergh has dispensed with makeup or excessive styling. He wants reality. But supermodels don't easily blend into the everyday. Dressed to the nines, interacting with no one, Lindbergh's subject is a slinky caricature of humanity, and the harder she tries to act pedestrian — staring ahead impassively, seemingly oblivious to the camera — the greater the visual discontinuity. The reader wants to place her on a Paris runway, not a filthy sidewalk.

Lindbergh Winogrand Women Photographs by Garry Winogrand and Peter Lindbergh. Koenig Books, 2017.

So we're back to apples and oranges. Interweaving Lindbergh's photos with Winogrand's is problematic. Yet the two photographers do share something in common. Both are prime exemplars of the male gaze. By his own admission Winogrand was particularly drawn to female subjects. "Whenever I saw a beautiful woman," he shrugged. "I gave my best to photograph her." Of course it wasn't just women. Winogrand was a rapacious people watcher and photographed everyone. But when his camera turned on women, street photography's exploitative nature and underlying power dynamics came to the fore.

If you buy the explanation offered by Ralph Goertz in the book's opening essay, Winogrand's male gaze was innocent enough. "Winogrand did not regard the women as objects," he surmises, "but he succeeded in bringing their inner beauty to the forefront." So Winogrand's Women Are Beautiful had nothing to do with objectifying the female body? Was it about "inner beauty" all along? That idea might come as a surprise to Helen Gary Bishop, who penned its introduction, or to the book's many perennial critics — it was generally panned upon release as shallow voyeurism, especially by feminists, and the criticism since has not abated.

Lindbergh Winogrand Women Photographs by Garry Winogrand and Peter Lindbergh. Koenig Books, 2017.

I don't mean to rehash Winogrand's sexism here. His male gaze may not be politically correct but it remains an essential strain in his character and his work. Of course since his time the photo world has generally become more aware and inclusive — helped along, ironically, by the critical reaction to Women Are Beautiful — bringing Winogrand's biases into sharper focus.

Lindbergh Winogrand Women
has a few production problems that hinder the effort. There are three essays, two of which are translated from German. Unfortunately these translations contain several grammatical errors and misspellings, and at least one short passage repeated erroneously. The layout into justified paragraphs is flawed. Some photographs are uncredited. A handful of Winogrand's color shots, published here for the first time and one of the book's highlights, is inexplicably missing captions. Eugene "Adget"'s name is misspelled. And so on. These errors are all minor. The real shame is they might have been ironed out with just a quick half hour of proofreading. The fact they remain in the book gives it a rushed, amateur quality. As a last small aside, the book's reproductions are somewhat dark and muddy.

Lindbergh Winogrand Women Photographs by Garry Winogrand and Peter Lindbergh. Koenig Books, 2017.

One corner of the photo universe where the male gaze remains ingrained and accepted is fashion. Surface appearance is prized above all. Youth, beauty, fitness, and gender are fetishized before being converted into images. Subsumed to the background are less visible traits, thoughts, and emotions, including Goertz's "inner beauty." In this environment the male gaze is integral. Thus, Lindbergh's infatuation with Winogrand seems quite natural. So perhaps fashion and street are not complete apples and oranges after all? Or at least the book hints in this direction, although perhaps unwittingly. "Two major photographers of the 21st century obsessed by women…" announces the jacket blurb, cementing the union without quite acknowledging its power dynamics. Like Women Are Beautiful, I suspect this book will give cultural critics material for years to come. — Blake Andrews

Purchase Book

BLAKE ANDREWS is a photographer based in Eugene, OR. He writes about photography at blakeandrews.blogspot.com.

Read more book reviews



photo-eye Gallery Celestial Photography:
Inspirations from the Sky
In light of the highly anticipated total solar eclipse happening across the United States on August 21st, 2017 photo-eye Gallery wanted to celebrate by selecting a handful of celestial inspired images from our flat files. Our curated selection includes exciting new work by represented artists Chris McCaw and Kate Breakey along with time-honored pieces by Linda Connor and Susannah Hays among others including Maggie Taylor, Cig Harvey, Chaco Terada and Alan Friedman.

In light of the highly anticipated total solar eclipse happening across the United States on August 21st, 2017 photo-eye Gallery wanted to celebrate by selecting a handful of celestial inspired images from our flat files. Our curated selection includes exciting new work by represented artists Chris McCaw and Kate Breakey along with time-honored pieces by Linda Connor and Susannah Hays among others including Maggie Taylor, Cig Harvey, Chaco Terada, Alan Friedman and Ernie Button.

To inquire, please contact the Gallery Staff at gallery@photoeye.com or 505-988-5152 x202.

May 28, 1900 © Linda Connor | Contact Print, Printing Out Paper, Gold Toned, 10 x 8"

Selection of Astronomical Orotones in Vintage Daguerreotype cases © Kate Breakey | Available in 2 sizes, each is unique.
Please inquire with Gallery Staff for pricing and availability. 

Sunburned GSP #910 (Utah), 2016 © Chris McCaw | Unique Silver-Gelatin Silver Paper Negative, 5 x 4"

Eclipse © Susannah Hays | Gelatin - Silver Print, 20 x 16", Edition of 25

Sadie & the Moon, Lake Megunticook, Maine, 2013 © Cig Harvey | C-Print, 28 x 28", Edition of 7
Star Dust IV © Chaco Terada | Archival Pigment Ink on Silk, 9 x 9", Edition of 3

Star gazer, 2015 © Maggie Taylor | Archival Pigment Print,  8 x 8", Edition of 15

2013 July 14 Summer Heat © Alan Friedman | Archival Pigment Print, 19 x 19", Edition of 15

Bowmore 135 © Ernie Button | Archival Pigment Print, 15 x 15", Edition of 20


Book of the Week Book of the Week: A Pick by John A Bennette John A Bennette selects Inundation by Kevin O'Connell as Book of the Week.
InundationBy Kevin O'Connell
Self-published, 2017.
John A Bennette selects Inundation  self-published by Kevin O'Connell as Book of the Week.

"Kevin O'Connell's Inundation is a limited edition, hand-sewn art object that is a serious argument for the continued creation of photobooks. From its subtly patterned and unmarked cover to its end papers, the unnumbered and textless body of images, and the title and poem at its end, Inundation is a quiet and reflective meditation about the sea.

These monochromatic, camera-based images of the sea are representational, yet near abstractions. Taken over a few years along Oregon’s Pacific coast, they evoke the mysterious ties that bind man to the great bodies of water. Inundation evokes Homer's wine-dark sea, the great 19th-century romantic musical compositions, and the solitary everyman staring into the vastness for answers. There is the foam of Zeus that gives birth, the calm ebb and flow, and the darkness of lost souls that becomes part of legends.

On every page of Inundation the image bleeds off the edge. There is no room for borders nor words. The photographer seeks to immerse you in the moments, as if to shut out the world as he shares what he emotionally sees with you. This is a book we can turn to when we need space to float above — or fall through — the depths of the world we know."
— John A Bennette

Purchase Book

InundationBy Kevin O'ConnellSelf-published, 2017.
InundationBy Kevin O'ConnellSelf-published, 2017.




John A Bennette is a collector, lecturer, editor, and curator. He has curated the Hearst 8x10 Photography Biennial and is the former art director and art editor for South X South East Photography Magazine.