PHOTOBOOK REVIEWS, INTERVIEWS AND WRITE-UPS
ALONG WITH THE LATEST PHOTO-EYE NEWS

Social Media

Book Review: America Latina


Book Review America Latina By Luis Camnitzer, Olivier Compagnon & Alfonso Morales Reviewed by Colin Pantall America Latina is a book of photographs from Latin America. That much is clear. It’s divided into four sections; Territory, The City, Memory and Resisting and Memory and Identity. What’s less clear is what Latin America actually is.

America Latina. By Luis Camnitzer, Olivier Compagnon
& Alfonso Morales. Thames & Hudson, 2014.
 
America Latina
Reviewed by Colin Pantall

America Latina: 1960 - 2013 Photographies
By Luis Camnitzer, Olivier Compagnon & Alfonso Morales.
Thames & Hudson, 2014. 400 pp., illustrated throughout.


America Latina, the catalog companion book to the exhibit of the same name that was presented at the Fondation Cartier pour l'Art Contemporain in Paris, is a book of photographs from Latin America. That much is clear. It’s divided into four sections; Territory, The City, Memory and Resisting and Memory and Identity.

What’s less clear is what Latin America actually is. In an essay at the front of the book, Oliver Compagnon tells us that it is a fictional creation that has little political or cultural meaning. It is a Eurocentric tag that ignores the indigenous peoples and the slaves who were traded from Africa. It’s a hugely diverse region with ranges of health, wealth and education that in some ways make it a meaningless term.

Compagnon believes there are reasons we should talk about Latin America. It has a revolutionary history that, for this book at least, begins with the Cuban Revolution and goes through to the victory of Nicaraguan Sandinistas in 1979. Latin America is also the home of ‘preventive coups;’ US-backed coups that established military led dictatorships in Brazil, Chile, Argentina and Uruguay. As we move into the 1990s and the US shifted its foreign policy eye to the Middle East, we see what Compagnon calls the ‘left turn;’ from being a testing ground for neo-liberal policies, it became the home of what seemed to be radical alternatives to neo-liberalism.

But still, Compagnon insists, Latin America is in a bad place. Crime rates are high, poverty endemic, the wealth gaps are widening and the legacy of colonial rule is still evident in the racial stratification of Latin American societies; "It is indeed no coincidence that the Spanish and Portuguese languages, as they are presently spoken throughout the continent, still contain hundreds of words for describing skin color, from the lightest shade to the darkest."

The sections of the book roughly correspond to these concerns and depict some common themes; strong graphic images, the use of text and the undermining of traditional forms of representation are all apparent as is the energy and anger of people living in communities and territories that seem to be in a constant state of flux.

Mapping comes up a lot in the first section, Territory. This includes the work of Claudio Perna, an artist who contrasts the distancing cartographical elements of maps with the human complexity of the lands they are supposed to represent. More maps come in the work of Elias Adasme, an artist who "…establishes a metaphorical relationship between his body and the nation’s map." So we see him hanging upside down next to a large map of Chile, a comment on the torture and disappearances of Chilean citizens.

In Marked, Claudia Andujar accompanied doctors who were vaccinating Yanomami people against a deadly measles epidemic. Andujar made medical cards that recorded the vaccinations; capturing her ambivalence at being part of a life-saving campaign but also questioning “…the method of labelling people for whatever ends.”

The City section is more documentary than the art-based work of Territory. Sistema Nervioso shows the graphic chaos of Caracas in the 1970s, while Siesta Argentina Facundo de Zuviria shows the small trades and shop fronts of Buenos Aires. Miguel Rio Branco’s dye destruction prints shows marginalized people living on the fringes of Rio de Janeiro and Jose Figueroa shows the contradictions apparent in the everyday propaganda of 1970s Havana.

Activism, text and collage come to the fore in the Memory and Resisting section. Violence, torture, disappearances and injustice are all remembered and recreated. Guillermo Deisler shows collages he made after he was exiled from Chile. One shows a clipping of General Pinochet and a text proclaiming his words: “Democracy carries whithin its breast the seed of its own destruction. There is a saying that democracy has to be bathed occasionally in blood so that it can continue to be democracy.” (sic)


Marcos Lopez flips the book into full colour mode in the Memory and Identity section with his portraits of brightly costumed Argentinians posing next to billboards and brands. What does it mean to be Argentinian in a world where everything is going global is the question he seems to be asking. And that’s what Latin America tries to answer; what it means to be Latin American in today’s globalised world, and what it means to make work that is distinctly Latin American, with a focus on graphics, memory and text.—COLIN PANTALL


COLIN PANTALL is a UK-based writer and photographer. He is a contributing writer for the British Journal of Photography and a Senior Lecturer in Photography at the University of Wales, Newport. http://colinpantall.blogspot.com

1 comment:

  1. This is a plot summary, not a review. How does documentary differ from "art-based work"? The reviewer tells us what the book "tries to answer" but expresses no opinion about the success or failure of this endeavor. C+

    ReplyDelete